Ontario
Toronto GTA
Downtown Toronto
Non-specialist
active
90463
male
2
Fluent in English
Registered as Postgraduate Education (from 23 Sep 2009)
Postgraduate Education (from 23 Sep 2009)
Registered on 01 Jul 2009
Graduated at Ross University in 2008
Postgraduate Training:
Assessment Verification Period at University of Toronto - Orthopedic Surgery (01 Jul 2009-22 Sep 2009)
PostGrad Yr 1 at University of Toronto - Orthopedic Surgery (23 Sep 2009-30 Jun 2010)
No associations
ServiceRating
Herman Singh Dhotar has received 6 rating(s) and 5 review(s), resulting in an average rating of 4.29 on a scale from 1 to 5. The overall rating for this medical doctor is excellent.
If you have personal experience with Herman Singh Dhotar, we encourage you to share that experience with our ServiceRating.ca community. Your opinion is very important and Herman Singh Dhotar will most certainly appreciate the feedback.
Joanne Beverley
Extremely good at his surgery..Anterior approach hip replacements. I would not hesitate to have him do my other hip if needed. Highly recommended him but be prepared for a wait.. He is so much in demand!
Was this review helpful to you? Rating [ 5.00 ]
Carol Hanson
I felt very comfortable with Dr. Dhotar. He explained the procedure for my total knee replacement, the recovery period and what my responsibilities were for a successful outcome. All of my questions were thoroughly and honestly answered. I have just had my 1 year visit/follow-up appointment, and I am very happy with the results. I would definitely recommend Dr. Dhotar.
Was this review helpful to you? Rating [ 5.00 ]
Gord Cosburn
Dr Dhotar was very honest pleasant. Did a great job. I recommend him to anyone needing a new knee. NYGH.
Was this review helpful to you? Rating [ 5.00 ]
Yvonne (Ivan) Pereira
Amazing, knowledgeable and very friendly dr. Very approachable and makes the patient very comfortable
Was this review helpful to you? Rating [ 5.00 ]
Ibrahim Barmada
**Extremely disappointing experience – serious consequences** I visited Dr. Herman Dhotar for a follow-up appointment on September 17, 2026, following a right ankle fracture. During that appointment, I specifically raised concerns about worsening swelling in my right calf and knee, along with significant knee pain. Unfortunately, my concerns were dismissed. I was told that his responsibility was limited to my ankle and foot, and that I should wait approximately another month for further investigation through a CT or MRI. No urgent investigation of the worsening swelling was arranged. On November 4, a Doppler ultrasound revealed extensive deep vein thrombosis (DVT) in my right leg, involving multiple veins. I am now dealing with two blood clots and the consequences of this diagnosis. I have been prescribed blood thinners for six months and must wear compression stockings until the swelling resolves. This has significantly affected my daily life, mobility, recovery and overall well-being. What makes this experience particularly frustrating is that I raised concerns about the worsening swelling directly with the doctor, yet they were not taken seriously or investigated with the urgency they deserved. I cannot help but question whether timely investigation could have prevented this situation or at least resulted in an earlier diagnosis and treatment. A patient should never feel that their concerns are being brushed aside, especially when potentially serious symptoms are involved. I expected proper medical attention, clinical judgment and a willingness to investigate symptoms beyond the original injury. Based on my experience, I would not recommend this physician.
Was this review helpful to you? Rating [ 1.00 ]
Profile ID: SRCA-MDS-P-62072